Skip to main content

3 Tips for Using Behavioral Science to Increase Direct Mail Response

Regardless of how you look at it, direct mail marketing isn't just successful - it's positively thriving. 

 
According to a recent study, approximately 73% of consumers say they prefer to be contacted by brands using direct mail rather than by alternative means like email. This preference is because they can read physical mail at their convenience. Not only that, but about 40% of direct mail recipients either fully read or, at the very least, scan what they receive - as opposed to something like an email that is far too easy to ignore.  

But as effective as direct mail is by its very nature, there are still ways to increase the engagement you can generate between you and the members of your target audience. Behavioral science is a great way to accomplish that, but it is a concept that will require you to keep a few critical things in mind. 

3 Tips for Using Behavioral Science to Increase Direct Mail Response 

Don't Neglect "Magnet" Words

One of the best ways you can use behavioral science to increase direct mail response is using what are called "magnet" words. 
 
People lead busy lives - you can only expect them to read some of the last words on a piece of direct mail marketing that you send out. What they're likely to do is skim. 
 
While doing so, if they see words like "now," "announcing," or "introducing," they're much more likely to pay attention. That's because these types of magnet words bring a natural sense of urgency, which can capture someone's interest and get them to pay attention to the rest of your message.  

Do Whatever You Can to Stand Out

Think briefly about all the mail you receive on a given day. 
 
Most of it probably looks incredibly similar - it's pieces of mail in a standard envelope size that are virtually indistinguishable from one another. Therefore, even something seemingly simple as sending out print marketing pieces that are an "unusual size" can be a great way to attract attention. It differentiates your marketing materials from everything else someone might receive that day. 
 
At the very least, it gets them to pay attention in a way that will likely be more engaging than something similar to everything else in their mailbox.  

The Power of Testimonials

Another of the best ways to use behavioral science to increase direct mail response involves including testimonials in your print marketing whenever possible. 
 
People aren't just going to take your word for it that your products and services can do what you say they can. They want to hear it from people they trust, and if they can't hear that from a friend or family member, that's okay - testimonials and quotes from honest, satisfied customers will work just as well. 
 
Testimonials show someone that another customer has been in a situation similar to the one they now find themselves in, and yours was the business that helped answer a question, solve a problem, or generally provide value to their lives in some way. Once the testimonial convinces them, they're much more likely to listen to the rest of what you have to say - which can get them to come down off the proverbial fence and make a purchase before you know it.  
 
If you'd like to find out more about increasing your direct mail response rates or have any additional questions, please don't hesitate to contact us today! 

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

When to Start Planning Your Year-End Print Projects (with Stats to Back It Up)

As the leaves start to turn, savvy marketers and business owners know it’s already time to think ahead; way ahead. Year-end print projects like calendars, holiday cards, and branded gifts aren’t just festive extras; they’re powerful tools for brand visibility, customer loyalty, and employee appreciation. But timing is everything. Here’s a breakdown of when to start planning each major print category and the data that proves why early birds really do get the worm. 🗓️ Calendars: Start Planning by   July–August Why so early? Calendars are long-lead items that require design, proofing, and often bulk mailing. They’re also one of the most visible branded items used daily, all year long. Stat to know: 80% of consumers hang onto promotional calendars for the entire year, and 76% recall the brand on them months later. Pro tip: Finalize your design by September to allow for production and distribution by October. 💌 Holiday Cards: Start Planning by August Whether you’re sending...
Post a Comment
Read more

Dad-Approved Print Marketing: Tough, Practical, and Built to Last

  Father’s Day may be behind us, but the dad energy lives on. You know what we’re talking about—classic dad traits: practical, no-nonsense, a little sarcastic, probably wearing cargo shorts, and definitely giving side-eye to your “modern” marketing campaign. And if we’re being honest? Your next print project could probably use a little more of that. So let’s take a moment—post-Father’s Day—to appreciate what dads (and dad-like marketing) have always done best: kept things simple, sturdy, and surprisingly effective. Here’s what your next print piece might look like if it were designed by everyone’s favorite unofficial brand strategist: Dad. 1. Paper So Thick It Could Be a Coaster If your brochure can't double as a shim for a wobbly table leg, your dad would probably question your paper choice. He doesn’t believe in flimsy print. Neither should you. Thick stock = serious message. 2. Fonts You Can Read From Across the Garage Your dad doesn’t “squint at design.” He wants to se...
Post a Comment
Read more

You Found Us—Now Let’s Make Something Brilliant Together

We’ve been doing a happy dance over here (printer-safe, of course) because our blog has seen a huge spike in readers lately—and we just want to say: thank you . Whether you’re a longtime follower or just stumbled in for a tip or two, we’re thrilled you’re here. Our mission? To make printing feel less like a mystery and more like a creative adventure. From clever packaging ideas to troubleshooting tips, we love sharing what we know—and we love hearing from you even more. 💬 Let’s Keep the Conversation Going If you’ve found something helpful, inspiring, or just plain fun here, don’t keep it to yourself! Comment below —ask us your burning printing questions, share your favorite tip, or just say hi. Share the blog with your team, your clients, or your fellow print nerds. The more, the merrier. Follow us on Facebook and X  for even more ideas, behind-the-scenes peeks, and quick tips you can actually use. We’re constantly posting new content to help you get the most out of your...
Post a Comment
Read more